112
Reviews
Craft Holsters - Holsters - 1911 Holsters - 1911 With Rail Holsters
Holsters for 1911 With Rail
How to choose the best holster for your 1911 with Rail
Start by confirming the rail type and barrel length. A 1911 5 inch with rail holster must accommodate the full-length slide and any tactical rail attachments. Choose a holster for 1911 with rail that maintains secure retention, ensures easy draw, and protects your handgun's finish. Materials like Kydex or molded leather provide consistent fit and durability. Evaluate your carry style—concealed or open—to narrow down the right design.
Best 1911 with Rail IWB Holster
IWB Holster w Steel Clip – $89. This leather holster can be carried both IWB and appendix style, offering flexibility in how you choose to carry your 1911 with Rail. The steel clip design is perfect for those who dislike removing their belt when attaching or detaching the holster. It also features a reinforced thumb break strap, adding extra durability and increasing the holster’s natural retention, making it a highly secure option.
Best 1911 with Rail OWB Holster
Open Top Belt Holster – $89. The Open Top Belt Holster is an excellent choice for those seeking easy access and a quick draw. Its pancake design provides a slim, low-profile fit, ensuring that your 1911 with Rail remains concealed even in an OWB carry position. This holster is not only practical but also extremely comfortable for daily wear.
Best 1911 with Rail Shoulder Holster
Shoulder Holster System – $215. For shoulder holster fans, the Shoulder Holster System is the best option for the 1911 with Rail. This leather shoulder system allows you to carry your gun in a horizontal position, secured with a thumb break strap for added safety. The system includes a double ammo holder and tie-down straps that attach to your belt, offering excellent balance and security. As a bonus, the holster can also be used as a regular belt holster, giving you two carry options in one.
Carry Options for 1911 5 inch with Rail holsters
Concealed Carry
The best holster for concealed carry depends on the size and weight of the 1911 With Rail. For this full-size handgun, IWB holsters are the most practical option, offering discreet carry while maintaining comfort. OWB holsters may work with appropriate outerwear, while shoulder holsters are suited for those prioritizing comfort over deep concealment.
IWB Holsters
An IWB holster for 1911 with rail offers deep concealment and secure placement inside the waistband. Look for features like adjustable cant, sweat guards, and reinforced retention to support the weight and size of a full-frame handgun. A quality IWB 1911 with rail holster will sit comfortably while keeping the firearm hidden beneath light clothing.
OWB Holsters
OWB holsters provide faster access and a more balanced draw. Ideal for range use or open carry, these holsters attach to the belt outside the waistband. A good holster for 1911 with rail in OWB style should contour closely to the body, offer secure fitment around the rail, and use double-stitched materials for reliability.
Shoulder Holsters
A shoulder holster 1911 with rail setup distributes weight across both shoulders, making it suitable for long periods of wear or seated carry. Choose an adjustable rig with horizontal or vertical orientation depending on your draw preference. Ensure the harness accommodates the extra rail bulk without shifting during movement.
Material Options for 1911 holster with Rail
Leather Holster for 1911 with Rail
Leather holsters offer excellent comfort and durability, molding to your body and firearm over time for a snug, glove-like fit. A leather holster for 1911 with rail made from premium full‑grain or Italian leather provides natural retention and protection while softening with use—often becoming comfier than synthetic options.
1911 with Rail Kydex Holsters
Kydex holsters are ultra‑lightweight and rigid, offering precise, custom molding that securely retains your firearm—even under demanding conditions—without needing a break‑in period. Their material resists chemicals and weather, provides adjustable retention (often reaching Level II–III), and delivers a satisfying “click” on draw and reholstering.
1911 with Rail Nylon Holsters
Nylon holsters are lightweight and cost-effective, made from durable, breathable materials like ballistic or Cordura nylon, making them ideal for concealed carry without adding bulk. Semi-universal designs molded around your firearm—and often compatible with similar-size guns—offer decent retention through body and belt pressure, especially for IWB use.
See Our Holsters in Action
In this demonstration, see how our holster for 1911 with Rail offers a blend of durability and discretion. The video illustrates the holster's ability to stay firmly in place while allowing quick access, making it ideal for daily carry.
Summary
Finding the best holster for 1911 with rail comes down to trust—trust that your full-size pistol will stay steady, protected, and ready the moment you need it. A quality rail-compatible holster should cradle the extra weight of the 5" 1911 without shifting, pinching, or slowing your draw. When the fit is right, the gun carries with surprising comfort, the draw feels natural, and the rig becomes a dependable part of your everyday routine.
Check favorite holster carry styles
About 1911 1911 (w Rail) - 5"
Gun Facts
| Barrel length: | 5" |
| Caliber: | 38/40/45/9 |
| Stack: | 3 |
| Width: | 1.25" |
| Height: | 5.5" |
| Length: | 8.5" |
Holsters for 1911 1911 (w Rail) - 5" reviews
5 reviews
Latest reviews
Sammy M.
The holster was not custom made because the snap on it does not allow for the cocked and locked carry. Even carrying with the hammer down the snap does not wrap over the hammer properly. The leather on the holster is ok but the rig is a very thin piece of leather with a plastic center pad on the back which from the way the rug pulls will break. No today but it’s not long lasting as I would expect from a craftsman claiming custom wear.
11/19/2025
United States
George K.
Absolutely a great well made good looking holster. This is the second paddle holster that I have ordered. Both are great. Very pleased!
02/05/2025
United States
Ed S.
Great quality !!!!!
03/22/2024
United States
Need a Holster for Another 1911?
Best Gun Holster Accessories
Choose the right accessories below that will enhance your carry. Don't forget that a proper magazine pouch, a belt or a concealed carry bag are always good choices.
MAGAZINE
POUCHES
Get yourself a custom mag pouch or speedloader pouch. Because there is never "enough ammo" right?
See Magazine Pouches
GUN BELTS
A solid and stable gun belt is what you need to prevent your holster and the rest of your EDC from sagging.
See Gun Belts
care kits
Don't forget to get yourself a handy kit that contains everything you need to make sure your holster will last you a lifetime.
See Care Kits
