462
Reviews
Craft Holsters - Holsters - Smith & Wesson Holsters - Smith & Wesson Highway Patrolman Holsters
Leather Holsters for Smith & Wesson Highway Patrolman
How To Choose The Best Leather Holster For Your Smith & Wesson Model 28 - 4"
When you're shopping for a new Leather holster for you.Smith & Wesson Model 28 - 4", knowing exactly what you want matters. If you've narrowed it down to a Leather holster, you're already on the right path. Below, we’ll walk you through why this carry style might be the ideal fit, how to find the best model for your body type and setup, and what materials and add-ons to consider.
A perfect Smith & Wesson M Leather {carry_style} holster holds your firearm without the need of a retention strap. The natural retention of each material takes care of it and you can even hold the scabbard upside down without the firearm falling of. Or you can rely on the retention strap which can have several levels of retention. Another treat of a great Smith & Wesson o Leather {carry_style} gunholster are smooth edges on the outside. This way the holster stays protected from abrasions, scratches or any other intrusive surfaces that it may stumble upon. A perfect finish of a Smith & Wesson d holster is another feature. A finished holster keeps dust, moisture and water away. Taking care of your holster is a important thing and there are many options including break-in or adjustment.
Choosing the best Leather holster for your Smith & Wesson Model 28 - 4" comes down to fit, comfort, and confidence. Whether you carry concealed every day or need something rugged for outdoor use, this carry style delivers dependable performance.
Holsters for Smith & Wesson Model 28 - 4" reviews
3 reviews
Latest reviews
Jay J.
It was delivered as promised. After I break it in and wear it a few times, I'll let you know. Jay
05/05/2025
United States
Steve W
Craft Holsters requested I submit a review on the Paddle Holster with Thumb Break. I am sorry to break there reported average rating of five stars from 380 reviews. I spent more than two weeks researching this type of holster and even called several of the manufacturers. My basic criterium included paddle style, thumb break, leather. The holster was ordered to fit a Smith and Wesson model 28-2 "Highway Patrolman" 357 magnum with a four inch barrel. Craft Holsters did not offer the color I wanted so I settled on mahogany. To my delight, the holster arrived about two weeks early. I had read and watched everything I could find in preparation of breaking in the new holster. I even ordered the break in liquid recommended by Craft Holsters. Of course, all of the literature, including Craft Holsters' recommendations, said the holster would arrive very tight and need to be stretched and molded to the gun. I unboxed the holster and slide the gun it. The gun "fit" but the holster was too wide; invert the holster and the gun falls right out. The after tightening the retention screw, there is no retention what so ever. Thank to the thumb break the holster will work, but it is not the fit I expected. Despite the fit of the holster, I found the adjustment of the paddle to be very easy. Obviously, the break-in fluid I ordered from Craft Holsters was a total waste of money as the holster did not require any break-in. I also order a speedloader case with this holster so they would be color matched. They are color matched but the diameter of the case is too small. I guess I will use the break-in fluid on the case and try to stretch it to fit. My final comment is in regards to the holster lining. I knew the holster was unlined but of the several holsters I own, it is the roughest on the inside. I will have to work on that as well. Will I use the holster? Sure; It will do. Will I used the speedloader case? Yes; if I can manage to stretch it out. Am I happy with this purchase? Unfortunately, no. I realize my gun is uncommon and most manufacturers do not offer a paddle back holster for it. I am grateful that Craft Holsters were at least willing to try.
09/20/2023
United States
George S.
Best holster I have. Outstanding.
06/29/2023
United States
Need a Holster for Another Smith & Wesson?
- Smith & Wesson SW1911 - 5"
- Smith & Wesson E-Series - 5"
- Smith & Wesson Pro Series - 3"
- Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 2.0 NTS
- Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 380
- Smith & Wesson CSX - 3.1"
- Smith & Wesson CSX E-Series - 3.1"
- Smith & Wesson Equalizer TS
- Smith & Wesson M&P - 4.25"
- Smith & Wesson M&P (cal .45) - 4.5"
- Smith & Wesson M&P (cal 5.7) - 5"
- Smith & Wesson M&P Compact - 3.5"
- Smith & Wesson M&P Compact (cal. 22) - 3.6"
- Smith & Wesson M&P 22 Magnum - 4.35"
- Smith & Wesson M&P M2.0 - 4.25"
- Smith & Wesson M&P M2.0 (cal .45) - 4.6"
- Smith & Wesson M&P M2.0 (cal 10mm) - 4"
- Smith & Wesson M&P M2.0 Compact - 4"
- Smith & Wesson M&P M2.0 Metal (cal. 9) - 4.25"
- Smith & Wesson M&P M2.0 Performance Center, COMPACT CARRY COMP - 4.22"
- Smith & Wesson M&P M2.0 SubCompact - 3.6"
- Smith & Wesson M&P M2.0 Tactical - 5"
- Smith & Wesson M&P M2.0 Pro Series - 5"
- Smith & Wesson M&P M2.0 CORE Pro Series - 5"
- Smith & Wesson M&P Shield - 3.1"
- Smith & Wesson M&P Shield 9 EZ - 3.675"
- Smith & Wesson M&P Shield 380 EZ - 3.675"
- Smith & Wesson M&P Shield EZ 30 Super Carry - 3.83"
- Smith & Wesson M&P Shield EZ M2.0 380- 3.675"
- Smith & Wesson M&P Shield EZ M2.0 9 - 3.8"
- Smith & Wesson M&P Shield M2.0 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson M&P Shield 9 Plus - 3.1"
- Smith & Wesson Performance Center M&P 9 Shield Plus Thumb Safety - 3.1"
- Smith & Wesson 22A
- Smith & Wesson 39
- Smith & Wesson 52
- Smith & Wesson 59
- Smith & Wesson 411
- Smith & Wesson 457
- Smith & Wesson 645
- Smith & Wesson 908
- Smith & Wesson 909
- Smith & Wesson 910
- Smith & Wesson 915
- Smith & Wesson 1006
- Smith & Wesson 1076
- Smith & Wesson 3904
- Smith & Wesson 3913
- Smith & Wesson 3914
- Smith & Wesson 4006 TSW (Round Trigger Guard)
- Smith & Wesson 4053
- Smith & Wesson 4506 Round Trigger Guard
- Smith & Wesson 4566TSW
- Smith & Wesson 5906 Square Trigger Guard
- Smith & Wesson 5943
- Smith & Wesson 6904 Square Trigger Guard
- Smith & Wesson 6906 Round Trigger Guard
- Smith & Wesson SD40VE
- Smith & Wesson SD9VE
- Smith & Wesson SW40C
- Smith & Wesson SW40F
- Smith & Wesson SW40V
- Smith & Wesson SW40VE
- Smith & Wesson SW9C
- Smith & Wesson SW9E
- Smith & Wesson SW9F - 4.5"
- Smith & Wesson SW9G
- Smith & Wesson SW9VE
- Smith & Wesson SW9V
- Smith & Wesson SW99 (cal 9mm)
- Smith & Wesson SW99 Compact
- Smith & Wesson Model 342 - 1.87"
- Smith & Wesson Model 581 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 38 - 1.9"
- Smith & Wesson Chief Special - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 31 - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 33 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 34 - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 36 - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 37 - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 40 - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 42 - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 43 C - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 60 - 3"
- Smith & Wesson Model 63 - 3"
- Smith & Wesson Model 317 Kit Gun - 3"
- Smith & Wesson Model 340 PD - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 350 - 7.5"
- Smith & Wesson Model 351 PD - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 360 PD - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 432 PD - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 437 FDE - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 442 - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 632 - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 637 - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 640 - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 642 - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 940 - 2.125"
- Smith & Wesson Model M&P340 - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model M&P360 - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model K-22 6"
- Smith & Wesson Model 10 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 11 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 12 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 13 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 14 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 15 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 16 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 17 - 6"
- Smith & Wesson Model 18 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 19 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 48 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 64 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Governor - 2.75"
- Smith & Wesson Model 65 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 66 - 4.25"
- Smith & Wesson Model 67 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 68 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 617 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 69 - 4.25"
- Smith & Wesson Model 386 - 2.5"
- Smith & Wesson Model 396 - 3"
- Smith & Wesson Model 586 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 619 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 620 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 681 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 686 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 686 Plus - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 986 - 5"
- Smith & Wesson Model 21 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 22 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 24 - 6.5"
- Smith & Wesson Model 25 - 6.5"
- Smith & Wesson Model 27 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 29 - 6.5"
- Smith & Wesson Model 57 - 6"
- Smith & Wesson Model 58 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 325 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 327 - 2"
- Smith & Wesson Model 327 TRR8 - 5"
- Smith & Wesson Model 329 Night Guard - 2.5"
- Smith & Wesson Model 329 PD - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 357 Night Guard - 2.5"
- Smith & Wesson Model 460V - 5"
- Smith & Wesson Model 610 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 625 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 627 - 2.6"
- Smith & Wesson Model 627 - 5"
- Smith & Wesson Model 629 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 629 - Stealth Hunter 7.5"
- Smith & Wesson Model 657 - 2.6"
- Smith & Wesson Model M&P R8 - 5"
- Smith & Wesson Model 500 - 4"
- Smith & Wesson Model 585 - 6"
Best Gun Holster Accessories
Choose the right accessories below that will enhance your carry. Don't forget that a proper magazine pouch, a belt or a concealed carry bag are always good choices.
MAGAZINE
POUCHES
Get yourself a custom mag pouch or speedloader pouch. Because there is never "enough ammo" right?
See Magazine Pouches
GUN BELTS
A solid and stable gun belt is what you need to prevent your holster and the rest of your EDC from sagging.
See Gun Belts
care kits
Don't forget to get yourself a handy kit that contains everything you need to make sure your holster will last you a lifetime.
See Care KitsBest Light / Laser Bearing Holsters
Light bearing holsters are built for shooters who need secure carry without giving up their weapon-mounted light or laser. Our selection of light bearing holsters is designed to fit popular attachments from Streamlight, SureFire, Olight, Holosun, Viridian, SIG Sauer, Inforce, Nightstick, and more, while still delivering reliable retention, comfort, and everyday practicality across multiple carry styles.
Holosun PID Holsters
Holosun PID Plus Holsters
Inforce Wild 1 Holsters
Inforce Wild 2 Holsters
Laser Max Ruger LCP Only Holsters
Nightstick TCM 550XL Holsters
Nightstick TSM-14G Holsters
Olight Baldr Mini Holsters
Olight Baldr Pro Holsters
Olight Baldr Pro R Holsters
Olight Baldr S Holsters
Olight PL-3 Valkyrie Holsters
Olight PL-Mini 2 Holsters
Olight PL-Mini Holsters
Olight PL-Pro Valkyrie Holsters
Olight PL-Turbo Valkyrie Holsters
Olight PL-3 R Holsters
SIG Sauer Foxtrot 365 XR Holsters
SIG Sauer Foxtrot 1X Holsters
SIG Sauer Foxtrot 2 Holsters
Streamlight TLR-6 Holsters
Streamlight TLR-8 Sub SIG Holsters
Streamlight TLR-8 Holsters
Streamlight TLR-1 HL Holsters
Streamlight TLR-1 HL-X Holsters
Streamlight TLR-2 Holsters
Streamlight TLR-7 Sub Holsters
Streamlight TLR-7 Sub Glock Holsters
Streamlight TLR-7 Sub Hellcat Holsters
Streamlight TLR-7 Sub SIG Holsters
Streamlight TLR-7A Holsters
Streamlight TLR-7X Holsters
Streamlight TLR-7 HL-X Holsters
Streamlight TLR-1 Holsters
Streamlight TLR-7 Holsters
Streamlight TLR-9 Holsters
SureFire X300U Holsters
SureFire X300U-A Holsters
SureFire X300U-B Holsters
SureFire X4000U Holsters
SureFire XSC Holsters
Viridian C5L Holsters
Viridian E Series FDE for Hellcat Holsters
If you prefer traditional carry without a weapon-mounted light or laser, you can explore our most popular classic holster styles. These include proven carry options such as shoulder leather holsters, OWB and IWB holsters, chest holsters, paddle holsters, cross draw holsters, pocket holsters, duty holsters, and other concealed carry designs. Each style offers a different balance of accessibility, concealment, and comfort, allowing shooters to choose the carry method that best fits their firearm, daily routine, and personal preference.
Shoulder Leather Holsters
Shoulder Nylon Holsters
OWB Leather Holsters
OWB Kydex Holsters
Chest Leather Holsters
Chest Nylon Holsters
IWB Leather Holsters
IWB Kydex Holsters
Concealed Carry Leather Holsters
Concealed Carry Kydex Holsters
Drop Leg Kydex Holsters
Paddle Leather Holsters
Paddle Kydex Holsters
Cross Draw Leather Holsters
Pocket Leather Holsters
Duty Leather Holsters
Duty Kydex Holsters
