Craft Holsters - Holsters - Smith & Wesson Holsters - Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Holsters
Leather Appendix Holsters for Smith & Wesson M&P Shield
Fan Favorite Holsters
All Holsters
How To Choose The Best Leather Appendix Holster For Your Smith & Wesson M&P Shield - 3.1"
When you're shopping for a new Appendix Leather holster for you.Smith & Wesson M&P Shield - 3.1", knowing exactly what you want matters. If you've narrowed it down to a Appendix Leather holster, you're already on the right path. Below, we’ll walk you through why this carry style might be the ideal fit, how to find the best model for your body type and setup, and what materials and add-ons to consider.
Why Choose an Appendix Holster?
Appendix holsters are designed to sit in the front of your waistband, typically between the 1 and 2 o'clock position. This carry method is favored by users who prioritize speed, concealability, and minimal printing.
Superior Concealment Up Front
Positioning the holster at the centerline of your body helps reduce printing, even under slim-fitting clothing. It also makes concealed carry easier to manage without layers or cover garments.
Fast, Natural Draw
Appendix carry gives you immediate access to your firearm, especially from a standing position. The hand naturally rests near the firearm, supporting a quicker draw compared to side or back positions.
Comfort in Movement
Modern appendix holsters are contoured to reduce pressure when sitting, bending, or driving. Features like sweat guards and padded backers help improve comfort during long wear periods.
Ideal for Vehicle Carry
Unlike strong-side holsters that shift or dig into your waist when seated, appendix holsters remain accessible and secure, even with a seatbelt engaged.
Retention Where You Need It
High-quality appendix rigs keep your Smith & Wesson M&P Shield - 3.1" firmly in place while allowing for a smooth, controlled draw. Most models include reinforced mouths for consistent reholstering and solid trigger guard coverage.
How to Choose the Right Appendix Holster for Your Build and Setup
Finding the best appendix holster means matching the design to your body shape, preferred ride height, and draw hand.
Body Type Considerations
Lean users often prefer slim, single-clip designs that disappear under clothing. For broader body types, a holster with a wing or wedge can help tuck the grip in, reduce printing, and distribute pressure more evenly.
Ride Height and Cant Adjustability
Look for a holster that lets you fine-tune ride height and cant angle. These adjustments help tailor concealment and comfort, especially if you carry with a tucked shirt or sit for extended periods.
Left- or Right-Handed Draw
Most appendix holsters are available in both left- and right-hand versions. Choose the correct configuration to match your dominant hand and practice consistent draw mechanics.
Additional Features
Some models include integrated mag pouches for added capacity. Others offer modular claw attachments to pull the grip in tighter. The best appendix holster is the one that supports your preferred carry setup without adding bulk.
Check out other holster carry styles
Be sure to check out what other carry styles we have:
A perfect Smith & Wesson S Leather Appendix holster holds your firearm without the need of a retention strap. The natural retention of each material takes care of it and you can even hold the scabbard upside down without the firearm falling of. Or you can rely on the retention strap which can have several levels of retention. Another treat of a great Smith & Wesson h Leather Appendix gunholster are smooth edges on the outside. This way the holster stays protected from abrasions, scratches or any other intrusive surfaces that it may stumble upon. A perfect finish of a Smith & Wesson i holster is another feature. A finished holster keeps dust, moisture and water away. Taking care of your holster is a important thing and there are many options including break-in or adjustment.
Choosing the best Appendix Leather holster for your Smith & Wesson M&P Shield - 3.1" comes down to fit, comfort, and confidence. Whether you carry concealed every day or need something rugged for outdoor use, this carry style delivers dependable performance.
Holsters for Smith & Wesson M&P Shield - 3.1" reviews
Latest reviews
Frederick S.
I love this holster it is very well made, and break in was no problem. All I know this is a quality holster and is well worth the money, it also fits IWB snug as a bug. Thank You Craft Holsters.
Steve
The metal clip is so stiff that it cannot be used to slide over a belt or pants which was the intended use. I have tried bending it out some which did not work. The clip would damage any belt of pants it was put over anyway. Guess this one is getting tossed. Don't think I will be buying anymore from this site.
Brian
I purchased dozens of holsters and magazine holsters. This holster has been my daily go to for more than 3 years. It holds my firearm in a magazine. I clip it in easily in the morning when I get up, when I get in and out of the car, or when I have to secure my firearm. The only time I'm not wearing it is it when I go to bed or in the shower. It's comfortable and accessible and does exactly what it's supposed to do. I bought a second one for my left hand in the event I get an injury. I bought multiples in case I lose one due to confiscation ( temporary of course). It conceals easily and nobody notices it. Holsters on my belt or back tend to stick up and out. Nobody notices this one on my appendix. I like that it's flexible and I can easily take it on and off.
Best Gun Holster Accessories
Choose the right accessories below that will enhance your carry. Don't forget that a proper magazine pouch, a belt or a concealed carry bag are always good choices.

MAGAZINE
POUCHES
Get yourself a custom mag pouch or speedloader pouch. Because there is never "enough ammo" right?
See Magazine Pouches
GUN BELTS
A solid and stable gun belt is what you need to prevent your holster and the rest of your EDC from sagging.
See Gun Belts
care kits
Don't forget to get yourself a handy kit that contains everything you need to make sure your holster will last you a lifetime.
See Care Kits