To main content
  • Home
  • Craft Holsters Blog
  • Leather Holsters Break-In & Care

Leather Holsters Break-In & Care

Leather is a natural product and leather holsters need care and maintenance to last a lifetime. This is a small guide that should cover all the needs of anyone that is looking for tips, tricks and how-to's about leather holsters. This is what you can find here:

3 Ways How To Deal With Leather Stiffness

  • Leather Holster Break-in With No Chemicals
  • Leather Strap Break-in With No Chemicals
  • Leather Holster Break-in - Alcoholic Way :)

Common Cases With Leather products

  • Cleaning
  • Scratch Removal
  • Minor Scratches
  • Deeper Scratches

3 Ways How To Deal With Leather Stifness

Sometimes it may happen that you may think we’ve sent you a wrong leather holster, because the gun doesn’t fit inside. Don’t worry, it’s just probably an issue which can be solved via a break-in. It’s a simple process that doesn’t require nothing more than just some household items and patience.

 Leather is a natural material that reacts to the environment, the temperature, moisture etc. It also needs some time to get used to anything it’s wrapped around. This is also true for our holsters. It may seem to you, that you've received a wrong one at first, but don’t worry, a simple break-in all that needs to be done. This guide will tell you how to do it.

 If you are asking why perfect fit holsters need a break in, the answer is wet shrinkage, which is caused by the crafting method. But that topic will not be discussed here, let’s return to the break-in.

Leather Holster Break-in With No Chemicals

You will need:

  • You gun
  • Our holster
  • Plastic Bag
  • Patience

Take your gun a put it in a plastic bag, this is done to increase the size of the gun in a small but effective size. Put the gun in the bag inside our holster. This may take a little bit of force, but don’t worry, the plastic bag not only increases the mass but also protects the gun from scratches or other damage. Let the gun in the bag sit in the holster overnight (or some 8 hours or so), draw it from the holster and remove the plastic bag. Now you should notice a change in the leather and your gun should fit in more precisely. If it’s still hard to holster the weapon, repeat this process.

It’s important to know, that there should be some sort of retention so don’t overdo the process. The holster will break-in naturally overtime, this is just a way of how to have a usable holster in no time.

Leather Strap Break-in With No Chemicals

You will need:

  • Your Gun
  • Our Holster
  • Some force

Straps really need attention and can't be broken-in in a matter of hours. They need care and sometimes a couple of days, if the leather is really sturdy. If you happen to have a problem getting the strap over the gun do as follows: grab the strap in your hand, between the thumb and index finger or whichever fingers you use and while holding the holster at the strap, insert the weapon inside. Push the gun inside and pull thestrap simultaneously in an opposite direction. You can twist and bend the strap for better effect. You can also stretch the strap while there is no gun in the holster, but having a gun increases the mass and force. If you decide to do it without the gun just stretch it repeatedly. Note that moving the strap from side to side or twisting it may harm the leather, so be careful! This whole process stretches the strap and seats the gun in the holster. After a while, try to pull the strap around the gun. You should find it easier now. If not repeat the process.

Leather Holster Break-in - Alcoholic Way :)

You will need:

  • Your Gun
  • Our Holster
  • Denatured Alcohol
  • Brush

If you want to stretch the snap you can do so with the help of chemicals. You can do the whole break-in as shown in the video below. For those who wish to read, the process is as follows: soak the brush in alcohol and apply the alcohol to the key points of the holster, which hold the gun inside such as  the trigger guard part. Rub the brush there a couple of times and this should do. Remember not to use any dressings, conditioners or mink oil which may soften the holster too much and render it useless. This procedure is all about knowing the exact amount.

The same method applies to the stretching of the snap. Just brush the alcohol on the inside part of the snap a couple of times and stretch and bend the snap. Pull the snap around the gun after a couple of tries and if it doesn’t stretch repeat the process.

You can also watch our video of a leather holster break in with denatured alcohol here.

Common Cases With Leather Products 

Your holster was scratched and you are on the brink of a mental breakdown. Not. You are a wise person who knows, that leather is a natural material that can be treated very simply. Here’s how.


Leather should be cleaned on a regular basis to avoid long-term harm. The best way to begin is to use a soft cloth or a microfiber cloth and dust the surface. A thin layer of a cleaning compound like saddle soap can be used to polish the holster surface. Another option is to lather the leather. Take a damp cloth and apply some moisturizing soap to it then rub the surface of the holster with it. For extra care apply some store-bought leather conditioner to prevent the holster from cracking and wrinkling.

 It’s recommended to clean and care for the outer part of the holster, the inside of the holster should be cleaned only if the objects or dirt are hindering a safe gun draw. The gun itself will shape the interior and doesn’t need any other interventions.

Removing Scratches

 Years of wear and harsh environments may lead to scratches on your holster. Some may take it as battle scars and some want to remove them. So in case you want to remove them read more. Identify the type of the scratch before you get to the point of removal. 

  • A minor scratch means that only the coating was harmed and the leather beneath is not harmed. This is the best case.
  • A deeper scratch means that the leather beneath the coating was harmed. The leather fibers may be visible. This is worse than the first one but can be fixed.
  • A cut through the leather is the worst part, it goes through the whole holster and a part of the gun is visible. This is the worst part which is non-repairable, but don’t worry, if you are in warranty it’s all ok, just contact us here.

Minor Scratches

Removing minor scratches is relatively easy work and  you’ll get used to it if they repeat themselves. You will probably deal with minor scratches most of the times, they are the easiest to repair. The leather ‘heals’ itself in most of the cases so you don’t have to worry about it being unpleasant to the eye.

Method no. 1

Rub some olive oil, baby oil or saddle oil into the scratch. Apply it directly with a cotton-swab applicator or a Q-tip by rubbing it into the scratch. Apply some of the oil also around in a circular motion. Let it rest for an hour then dry it and wipe it with a cloth. If it isn’t repaired on the first try, repeat it. Also please note, that leather absorbs the oil and may become slightly darker.

Method no. 2

Apply lanolin to the scratch and rub it around with a cloth, possibly a cotton one. Rub it across the scratched area, perpendicular to the direction of the cut. This is a lengthy process and will take more time before the scratch disappears. Please note that lanolin also may change the color tone of the holster so rub it firstly on some older leather holster or to an area which isn’t visible.

Method no. 3 

Apply shoe polish with a matching color to the surface scratch of the holster. Apply it firstly with a clean cloth or a cotton-swab applicator directly to the scratch on the surface. Then rub the shoe polish onto the leather and remove it with a clean cloth afterwards. Please note that this process won’t heal the scratches, but it disguises them. If you didn’t match the colors at first just remove the applied polish, clean the holster, dry it and apply another layer with a better color tone.

Deeper Scratches

Deeper scratches may take a little longer to ‘heal’ but the leather and holster functionality won’t be affected in any way. Note that the scratch won't be repaired and healed competely, the scratch wil remain visible because the very fiber of the leather beneath the finish was damaged. These scratches are just taken care of with the method below to the point of not spreading or affecting the functionality of the holster.

Method no. 1

Apply rubbing alcohol to the scratch. Be sure to clean the leather before applying the alcohol to maximize the effects of it. Rubbing alcohol dries quickly, so you can repeat the process each 10-15 minutes to achieve your desired look.

What To Do And What Not To Do with Your Leather Holster

We can provide you with any information, but unless you don't have in mind these small yet very important facts, you will find yourself caring and repairing the holster a lot more often. Please have in mind that not only guns need cleaning and maintenance but holsters need it as well.

The things you want to do


  • Do clean the holster with a soft cloth and mild soap. A gun holster that comes in contact with perspiration on a regular basis may need to be treated as outlined above as often as once a month
  • Do work soap and a small amount of water into the leather and apply to the surface, rub in and wipe off with a soft cloth (once every 3-4 months)
  • Do allow the leather to air dry naturally, without any type of artificial heat
  • Do use a small amount of a neutral leather cream or a bit of cooking oil to slow the natural breakdown of the leather

The things you don't want to do


  • Do not submerge or saturate your leather in water or other liquid, as they will saturate and soften the leather too much. It may cause the holster to lose its shape
  • Do not dry your leather product with any type of artificial heat (hair dryer, oven, radiator, direct sunlight)
  • Do not leave your leather products on the dashboard of the car in the summer, or leave it otherwise exposed to the elements Following our recommended care tips, will allow you to get the maximum service life from your leather products.

Craft Holsters Leather Holster Return Policy

In case you do all the actions mentioned above and your holster outlives the lives of other holsters and yet it seems rugged and about to fall apart just hit us with an email and send us a picture of the veteran you have and we will help you get a new one with a discount. Send the email to and don't forget to include:

  • Your Order Number
  • The Picture Of The Holster