Smith and Wesson 686 Review: Specifications, Performance, and Price

 

Smith and Wesson is well-regarded for producing high-quality firearms, particularly known for their reliable revolvers, concealed carry pistols, and budget-friendly handguns. The Smith and Wesson 686 revolver was introduced in the 1980s to meet the demand for a durable, high-performance revolver that could handle .357 Magnum rounds with ease, making it suitable for both defense and range shooting.

The Smith and Wesson 686 specs include a robust stainless steel construction, a 4-inch barrel, and a six-round cylinder capacity, giving it both durability and balanced handling. Known for its impressive accuracy and manageable recoil, the Smith and Wesson 686 performance is ideal for those who need a powerful, reliable firearm. Priced around $850, this revolver offers a solid investment for quality and performance.

Check out our comprehensive Smith and Wesson 686 review, discussing the main specs, performance, and price of the Smith & Wesson 686. Keep on reading to find out what makes the Smith and Wesson 686 one of the best revolvers for versatile use.

 

 

Smith and Wesson 686: Background & First Impressions

 

The origin of the S&W 686 lies in the manufacturer's goal to produce a durable, versatile revolver capable of handling the demands of both target shooting and personal defense. The Smith and Wesson 686 release date landed in 1980, and it entered the market as part of the esteemed L-frame series, specifically designed to withstand the higher pressures of .357 Magnum rounds. This model takes design inspiration from the classic Smith and Wesson Model 66 but boasts a sturdier frame and a thicker barrel to better manage recoil.

When I first laid my hands on the 686, I immediately appreciated its robust yet balanced feel. The grip fills the hand just right, giving a sense of solid control with each shot. This Smith and Wesson revolver is built for shooters who need reliability and power, offering a fine balance between heft and comfort, making it an ideal choice for anyone serious about both performance and durability.

 

Key Features of Smith and Wesson 686

 

The Smith and Wesson 686 features a .357 Magnum caliber with a six-round capacity, providing ample stopping power for self-defense and range shooting. Constructed with a stainless steel frame and cylinder, this revolver is built for durability, offering a solid heft that absorbs recoil well while maintaining longevity. With a 4-inch barrel length, the Smith and Wesson 686 size balances control and portability, making it a versatile choice for both home defense and target shooting.

One of the primary benefits of the Smith & Wesson 686 is its manageable recoil, which enhances accuracy and comfort even for extended shooting sessions. However, a notable Smith and Wesson 686 problem is its weight, which may make it less ideal for concealed carry. All in all, the Smith and Wesson 686 delivers a combination of reliability and power, suited to shooters who prioritize performance and durability.

 

Main Specs of Smith and Wesson 686

 

The Smith and Wesson 686 is built around a robust 4-inch barrel, striking a balance between accuracy and manageable size for versatile use. Chambered in .357 Magnum with a six-round capacity, this revolver provides substantial power for both home defense and range shooting. Its stainless steel construction adds durability, ensuring it stands up to heavy use while also giving it a well-balanced feel. Let’s dive into the main specs that highlight the S&W 686’s reputation among revolver enthusiasts.

 

Smith and Wesson 686 Specs	Smith and Wesson 686 Spec Value
Caliber	.357 Magnum
Cylinder Capacity	6 rounds
Height	5.5 inches
Width	1.5 inches
Overall Length	9.6 inches
Barrel Length	4 inches
Front Sight	Red Ramp
Rear Sight	Adjustable White Outline
Frame Material	Stainless Steel
Frame Size	Medium-L Frame
Action Type	Double-Action/Single-Action
Weight	40 ounces
Price	Approximately $850

 

Smith and Wesson 686 Pros and Cons

 

The pros and cons of the Smith and Wesson 686 highlight its suitability as a powerful, reliable revolver, while also noting a couple of practical drawbacks. A primary advantage of the Smith and Wesson 686 is its robust stainless steel frame, which not only enhances durability but also effectively manages recoil, providing better control and accuracy—particularly useful for both target shooting and home defense. On the downside, the revolver's weight of 40 ounces can make it cumbersome for prolonged carry, potentially limiting its practicality as a concealed carry option. These pros and cons of Smith and Wesson 686 illustrate its appeal for those who prioritize power and durability, despite the trade-off in portability.

 

What are the main advantages of Smith and Wesson 686?

 

The Smith and Wesson 686 offers a variety of benefits, making it a top choice for shooters who prioritize power and control. The main Smith and Wesson 686 advantages are outlined below.

• Durable Stainless Steel Build: One of the primary Smith and Wesson 686 pros is its stainless steel frame, which provides exceptional durability and longevity, even with frequent use.
• Effective Recoil Management: Thanks to its weight and robust construction, the 686 absorbs recoil well, allowing for better control and accuracy during shooting.
• Versatile .357 Magnum Chambering: The revolver’s .357 Magnum caliber, which can also accept .38 Special rounds, offers versatility for both target practice and self-defense.
• Adjustable Sights: Equipped with an adjustable rear sight, the S&W 686 enables precise aiming, making it suitable for a range of shooting distances.

These Smith and Wesson 686 benefits underscore its appeal as a reliable, versatile revolver with durability and performance as standout features.

 

What are the main disadvantages of Smith and Wesson 686?

 

Just like previously mentioned, the biggest disadvantage of the Smith and Wesson 686 is its weight, which can make extended carry uncomfortable. In addition, several users have identified other Smith and Wesson 686 problems, as outlined below. Fortunately, most of these Smith and Wesson 686 issues are manageable with adjustments or alternative choices. Check out our blog on the most frequent Smith and Wesson 686 problems and learn how to effectively solve them.

• Heavy Weight: The Smith and Wesson 686’s 40-ounce build can make it cumbersome to carry, especially for all-day use.
• Size for Concealed Carry: Due to its larger frame, the 686 may not be ideal for concealed carry, limiting its portability options.
• Higher Price: The Smith and Wesson 686’s quality and durability come with a higher price point, which may be a barrier for budget-conscious buyers.

These Smith and Wesson 686 disadvantages are points to consider, but they don’t overshadow its reputation as a reliable, powerful revolver.

 

Best Upgrades for Smith and Wesson 686

 

Upgrading your Smith and Wesson 686 with aftermarket accessories can enhance its performance, accuracy, and handling, making it even more versatile for various shooting applications. One of the most popular Smith and Wesson 686 upgrades is an enhanced grip, which improves comfort and control, especially when managing the recoil of .357 Magnum rounds. Another effective improvement involves installing aftermarket sights, like fiber optic or night sights, which increase visibility and speed up target acquisition in low-light conditions.

Additionally, a trigger upgrade can reduce pull weight, allowing for smoother and more precise firing. These aftermarket accessories for Smith & Wesson 686 provide opportunities to customize the revolver to better suit your shooting preferences.

 

What are the best Smith and Wesson 686 accessories?

 

Equipping your Smith & Wesson 686 with top-quality accessories can greatly improve its comfort, performance, and adaptability. Below are some of the best Smith and Wesson 686 accessories available.

 

• Best Smith and Wesson 686 Grips: The Hogue Monogrip provides an ergonomic fit and a textured surface, which helps in controlling recoil and offers comfort during extended shooting sessions.
• Best Smith and Wesson 686 Sights: TruGlo TFX Pro sights are highly recommended for their bright, tritium fiber optics, delivering clear visibility in all lighting conditions for quick target acquisition.
• Best Smith and Wesson 686 Red Dots: For enhanced accuracy, especially during long-range shooting, the Trijicon RMR Type 2 is an excellent red dot sight option, well-suited for the Smith and Wesson 686. For secure carry with optics attached, consider the Smith and Wesson 686 Scoped Leather Chest Holster, designed to accommodate red dot-equipped 686 models comfortably.
• Best Smith and Wesson 686 Gun Belts: The 1.5'' Leather Belt is a durable choice, providing solid support for carrying the S&W 686 securely and comfortably.
• Best Smith and Wesson 686 Speedloaders: The HKS 586-A speedloader enables quick and reliable reloading, especially useful in high-pressure scenarios.
• Best Smith and Wesson 686 Holsters: Let’s now take a closer look at the best Smith and Wesson 686 holsters to ensure you have an ideal carry option for this revolver.

 

These accessories combine to optimize the Smith and Wesson 686’s usability and effectiveness across various shooting needs.

 

 

Smith and Wesson 686 Holsters: How to Choose the Best Holster for Smith and Wesson 686?

 

Smith and Wesson 686 holsters are essential accessories that enhance the safety, accessibility, and overall functionality of this powerful revolver. Choosing the best Smith and Wesson 686 holster ensures your firearm remains secure and easily accessible when you need it most.

To select the best holster for Smith & Wesson 686, begin by considering your intended use. For everyday carry, opt for a holster with a comfortable profile that suits your lifestyle, such as an IWB (Inside the Waistband) for discreet carry or an OWB (Outside the Waistband) for range or open carry. The carry style matters, as it affects both comfort and accessibility. Material is another factor: leather offers a comfortable, classic feel, while kydex provides a molded fit for enhanced retention. If your 686 has accessories like a scope or laser, be sure to choose a holster designed to accommodate these upgrades.

By focusing on intended use, carry style, material, and compatibility with accessories, you can find the best Smith and Wesson 686 holsters that fit your specific needs and enhance your carry experience.

 

What are the best Smith and Wesson 686 concealed carry holsters?

 

For effective concealed carry, the best Smith and Wesson 686 concealed carry holsters offer a blend of comfort, accessibility, and concealment tailored to various carry preferences.

• Smith and Wesson 686 IWB Holsters: Inside-the-waistband (IWB) holsters are ideal for keeping the 686 close to the body, offering excellent concealment under most clothing while maintaining easy access. This style is a top choice for everyday concealed carry.
• Smith and Wesson 686 OWB Holsters: While outside-the-waistband (OWB) holsters may provide slightly less concealment, they allow for a faster draw and can still be hidden effectively with a jacket or loose garment, making them suitable for those prioritizing quick access.
• Smith and Wesson 686 Shoulder Holsters: Shoulder holsters are a great option for cooler weather when jackets can cover the firearm comfortably off the waist, providing an alternative carry method that's easy to access.
• Smith and Wesson 686 Chest Holsters: Chest holsters offer secure carry, especially useful for outdoor or active scenarios where waist carry may not be practical, ensuring the revolver is always within reach.

These Smith and Wesson 686 concealed carry holsters present versatile options, allowing you to select the best style to meet your specific carry needs and lifestyle preferences.

 

Best Smith and Wesson 686 IWB Holster

 

The best IWB holster for Smith and Wesson 686 is the Smith and Wesson 686 IWB Holster with Steel Clip, an excellent choice for comfortable, discreet carry. This Smith and Wesson 686 inside waistband holster is crafted from premium leather, ensuring both durability and a natural fit that contours to the body for all-day comfort.

This Smith and Wesson 686 concealed holster features a reinforced steel clip, providing secure attachment to the waistband while allowing easy removal when needed. Its low-profile design enhances concealment, making it ideal for those who want to keep their revolver close and discreet. For anyone looking for a high-quality, reliable Smith and Wesson 686 IWB holster, this model combines comfort, security, and ease of access, making it a top choice for everyday carry.

 

Best Smith and Wesson 686 OWB Holster

 

The best OWB holster for Smith and Wesson 686 is the Smith and Wesson 686 Comfortable Belt Holster, an ideal option for secure and comfortable outside waistband carry. This Smith and Wesson 686 outside waistband holster is crafted from premium leather, offering both durability and a custom-molded fit that holds the revolver firmly in place.

This Smith and Wesson 686 belt holster is designed to keep the firearm close to the body, providing effective concealment when worn under a jacket or loose clothing. Its slightly forward cant ensures an ergonomic angle, allowing for quick, unobstructed draws. For anyone in search of a high-quality Smith and Wesson 686 OWB holster, this model offers a balanced combination of comfort, secure carry, and accessibility, making it a top choice for everyday use.

 

Best Smith and Wesson 686 Shoulder Holster

 

The best shoulder holster for Smith and Wesson 686 is the Smith and Wesson 686 Vertical Roto Shoulder Holster System, an excellent option for those who prioritize comfort and accessibility during extended wear. This Smith and Wesson 686 shoulder holster is designed to carry the firearm securely under the arm, making it ideal for concealed carry beneath a jacket.

Equipped with fully adjustable shoulder straps, this rig provides a personalized fit that ensures balanced weight distribution, reducing shoulder strain and enhancing comfort throughout the day. The holster system includes a double speedloader pouch, giving you convenient access to extra rounds when needed. For anyone seeking a reliable Smith and Wesson 686 shoulder holster, this model offers durable construction, comfort, and practical features for a streamlined carrying experience.

 

Best Smith and Wesson 686 Chest Holster

 

The best chest holster for Smith and Wesson 686 is the Smith and Wesson 686 Leather Chest Holster, a superb option for outdoor enthusiasts and those needing secure, hands-free carry. This Smith and Wesson 686 chest holster is crafted from premium leather, offering durability and comfort even during extended wear.

Designed for easy access, this chest holster positions the revolver at the center of your chest, making it ideal for activities like hiking, fishing, or other outdoor tasks where waist or shoulder carry may not be practical. With adjustable straps, it ensures a comfortable, customized fit that keeps your firearm secure and ready for quick draw. For anyone seeking the best chest holster for Smith and Wesson 686, this model combines ruggedness, accessibility, and convenience, making it a reliable choice for active carry.

 

 

Why Choose Smith and Wesson 686 Over Other Handguns?

 

Choosing the Smith and Wesson 686 over other handguns offers clear benefits, particularly for those who value power, durability, and versatility in a revolver. Chambered in .357 Magnum and featuring a 4-inch barrel, the SW 686 delivers reliable stopping power and accuracy, making it a top choice for both home defense and range shooting.

What sets the Smith & Wesson 686 apart is its robust stainless steel construction, which enhances durability and helps manage recoil effectively, allowing for precise follow-up shots. The combination of its medium-L frame size, adjustable sights, and six-round capacity make it versatile enough for multiple uses, from target practice to self-defense. This blend of performance, reliability, and adaptability makes the Smith & Wesson 686 a standout option for those seeking a dependable, all-purpose revolver.

 

How does Smith and Wesson 686 differ from Smith and Wesson 686 Plus?

 

The primary difference between the Smith and Wesson 686 and the Smith and Wesson 686 Plus is cylinder capacity. The standard Smith and Wesson 686 holds six rounds, while the S&W 686 Plus is designed to hold seven rounds, providing an additional shot before reloading.

Functionally, both models are nearly identical, sharing the same .357 Magnum chambering, 4-inch barrel length, and durable stainless steel construction, which makes them reliable choices for both range shooting and self-defense. However, the extra round in the 686 Plus offers a slight advantage for users who value extended capacity without sacrificing the performance and durability typical of the 686 series. This difference makes the Smith and Wesson 686 Plus ideal for those who prefer a higher-capacity revolver while retaining the same solid features of the original model.

 

How does Smith and Wesson 686 differ from Colt Python?

 

The main differences between the Smith and Wesson 686 and the Colt Python revolve around construction, trigger feel, and price point. The Smith and Wesson 686 is built with a medium-L frame and uses a stainless steel construction, known for its robustness and ability to handle heavy shooting sessions, making it a durable and accessible choice. In contrast, the Colt Python features a larger, more robust frame, often praised for its superior craftsmanship and high-polish stainless steel finish, giving it a classic, high-end appeal.

Another key distinction is in the trigger performance. The Colt Python is renowned for its smooth, consistent trigger pull, which many shooters consider one of the best in the revolver category. While the S&W 686 also has a reliable double-action/single-action trigger, it lacks the refined feel that the Python's trigger mechanism offers. These differences make the Smith & Wesson 686 an excellent, practical option for everyday use and range shooting, while the Colt Python is often favored by collectors and enthusiasts willing to invest in a premium revolver with a storied reputation.

 

Frequently Asked Questions about Smith and Wesson 686

 

Now that we've been through everything you need to know about the Smith and Wesson 686, let's wrap it up by answering some of the Smith and Wesson 686 frequently asked questions. These will help clarify any remaining details and provide further insights into this durable and versatile revolver, making sure you're fully informed before making your choice.

 

 

Conclusion: Is Smith and Wesson 686 Worth It?

 

The Smith & Wesson 686 is absolutely worth considering for anyone seeking a powerful, versatile revolver with excellent specifications, performance, and solid value. Its durable stainless steel build, reliable .357 Magnum chambering, and balanced 4-inch barrel make it a top choice for both home defense and range shooting, offering a combination of durability and accuracy.

This revolver is ideal for shooters who value power, precision, and robust construction without compromising on ease of handling. When paired with the right Smith and Wesson 686 holster, it becomes an even better option, ensuring secure, comfortable carry and quick accessibility. Personally, I recommend the S&W 686 for its balance of power and control—it’s a revolver I’d trust for both protection and enjoyment at the range, making it a well-rounded choice for serious gun enthusiasts.