Table of Contents
The Smith and Wesson 686, crafted by one of the most reputable firearm manufacturers, Smith and Wesson, has been a popular choice since its release for those seeking a powerful and reliable .357 Magnum revolver. Known for its sturdy stainless steel construction and excellent accuracy, the Smith & Wesson 686 is frequently used for self-defense, home protection, and even in the field. Its combination of durability and firepower makes it a standout revolver for both seasoned shooters and enthusiasts alike.
However, while many consider the Smith and Wesson 686 a top-tier revolver, it does come with a few common issues that can impact its performance. In this article, we’ll explore the most frequent Smith and Wesson 686 problems and, importantly, provide practical solutions for each. By the end, you'll know how to tackle these challenges and decide if the Smith and Wesson 686 is truly worth adding to your collection. Read on to learn more about the most common Smith and Wesson 686 problems and how to resolve them effectively.
Meet Smith and Wesson 686: Main Specs & Problems Outlined
The Smith and Wesson 686 is a robust .357 Magnum revolver featuring a 4-inch barrel, designed primarily for self-defense and duty use. Built with a stainless steel frame and barrel, the S&W 686 combines durability with a balanced weight that handles recoil effectively. This revolver includes a six-round cylinder, adjustable rear sights, and a front red ramp sight, allowing for precise aim and control. As a versatile Smith and Wesson revolver, it appeals to both seasoned shooters and those new to revolvers, thanks to its solid build and manageable recoil.
Wanna dive deeper into the main features of the Smith and Wesson 686? Check out our detailed Smith and Wesson 686 review to see why it's a revolver worth experiencing.
In terms of issues, the Smith and Wesson 686 has a few common challenges that I’ve come across, including occasional cylinder binding, ejector rod loosening, and heavy trigger pull weight. These problems can impact reliability and shooting comfort, but each has practical solutions. Alright, without further ado, let's take a detailed look at the most troublesome Smith and Wesson 686 issues and how they can be easily solved.
Smith and Wesson 686 Problems: Smith and Wesson 686 cylinder binding issue and how to fix it
One of the most common issues with the Smith and Wesson 686 is cylinder binding, which can disrupt the revolver’s functionality and reliability. Cylinder binding generally occurs when residue buildup, heat expansion, or a misalignment causes the cylinder to lock up or rotate sluggishly. In the Smith & Wesson 686, this problem can become noticeable after extended firing sessions, as the heat and powder residue accumulate, especially with .357 Magnum rounds.
This binding issue can be frustrating in defensive or fast-paced shooting scenarios, as it interrupts the firing rhythm and can prevent quick follow-up shots. For users accustomed to smooth cylinder action in other revolvers, the SW 686’s occasional binding can feel like a notable drawback, impacting the overall confidence in the gun's reliability.
How to solve Smith and Wesson 686 cylinder binding problem
To address the cylinder binding problem in the Smith and Wesson 686, start by thoroughly cleaning and lubricating the cylinder and ejector rod after each use. Powder residue buildup is a frequent cause of binding, especially after firing .357 Magnum rounds, which produce more fouling. Using a high-quality gun cleaner on the cylinder's internal and external surfaces can prevent this issue from worsening over time.
If regular cleaning doesn’t completely resolve the problem, consider inspecting the ejector rod for tightness, as a slightly loose rod can cause misalignment and binding. Tightening the ejector rod gently can help realign the cylinder and improve its rotation without affecting other components.
Smith and Wesson 686 Problems: Smith and Wesson 686 ejector rod loosening issue and how to fix it
Another frequent problem with the Smith and Wesson 686 is the loosening of the ejector rod, a component essential for smooth cylinder operation and reliable performance. When the ejector rod becomes loose, it can lead to misalignment within the cylinder, causing it to rotate unevenly and, in some cases, prevent the cylinder from opening or closing properly. This can be especially frustrating during high-stakes situations or extended shooting sessions, where seamless operation is crucial.
The ejector rod loosening is a common issue in revolvers like the Smith & Wesson 686, particularly after prolonged use or repeated exposure to the powerful recoil of .357 Magnum rounds. Over time, the vibrations and force from firing can gradually loosen the ejector rod, affecting the gun’s reliability. For shooters who depend on the S&W 686 for consistent performance, this issue is not only inconvenient but can also undermine confidence in the revolver’s readiness in critical moments.
How to solve Smith and Wesson 686 ejector rod loosening problem
To fix the ejector rod loosening issue on the Smith and Wesson 686, start by carefully tightening the rod using a non-marring tool to avoid damaging its threads. The ejector rod is reverse-threaded, meaning it tightens counterclockwise, so be sure to turn it in the correct direction. Tightening the ejector rod should restore cylinder alignment and prevent it from loosening due to recoil vibrations over time.
If you find the rod continues to loosen, applying a small amount of thread-locking compound can provide extra security, though this should be done sparingly to avoid impeding future maintenance.
Smith and Wesson 686 Problems: Smith and Wesson 686 heavy trigger pull weight issue and how to fix it
A common issue with the Smith and Wesson 686 is its notably heavy trigger pull weight, which can significantly impact both shooting precision and user comfort. The factory double-action trigger pull on the Smith & Wesson 686 is generally around 11 to 12 pounds. While this weight may contribute to safety by reducing the chance of an accidental discharge, it can be excessive for users who require a smooth, rapid firing experience. For those who depend on quick and accurate follow-up shots, especially in defense or competitive shooting scenarios, the heavy trigger pull can slow down response time and disrupt shooting rhythm.
This substantial trigger weight can also lead to hand fatigue, particularly during extended practice sessions. For shooters accustomed to lighter triggers in other revolvers, the SW 686’s trigger can feel burdensome and even impact accuracy, as the added effort to complete each pull may lead to slight shifts in grip or aim.
For users who rely on the S&W 686 in high-stakes situations, such as self-defense or competition, the effort required to pull the trigger becomes a factor of both performance and comfort, which can undermine confidence in critical situations.
How to solve Smith and Wesson 686 heavy trigger pull weight problem
To address the heavy trigger pull weight on the Smith and Wesson 686, start by thoroughly cleaning and lubricating the internal components of the trigger assembly. Over time, residue buildup can increase resistance, making the trigger feel even heavier than its default 11 to 12 pounds. Proper maintenance can help mitigate this and lead to a smoother, more consistent pull.
For those seeking a more noticeable reduction, replacing the factory rebound spring with a lighter one is a popular modification. This adjustment can reduce the effort needed to pull the trigger without significantly impacting the revolver's safety or reliability. Some shooters also choose to have a gunsmith perform a trigger job, which involves polishing and tuning internal components for a smoother and lighter pull. These modifications are particularly beneficial for users who rely on the 686 in competitive or defensive settings, where speed and accuracy are essential.
Smith and Wesson 686 Problems: Choosing the right Smith and Wesson 686 holster
Choosing the right Smith and Wesson 686 holster is crucial for both safety and functionality, as it keeps your revolver secure and accessible in various scenarios. When selecting Smith and Wesson 686 holsters, consider factors such as intended use, your level of experience, preferred carry style, and material options.
- If you plan to carry concealed, an inside-the-waistband (IWB) holster provides a low-profile fit, while outside-the-waistband (OWB) holsters are ideal for open carry or range sessions.
- Your experience level also matters—newer shooters may prefer holsters with adjustable retention for added security, while experienced users might prioritize a quick and smooth draw.
- Carry style is another key factor; appendix carry holsters balance concealment and accessibility, while strong-side holsters work well for OWB setups.
- Finally, material choice plays a role: leather offers comfort and a custom fit over time, while kydex provides durability and rigidity, ideal for outdoor activities.
Selecting the right Smith and Wesson 686 holster enhances comfort, accessibility, and confidence in any setting.
Best Smith and Wesson 686 holsters by Craft Holsters
For the best Smith and Wesson 686 holster, Craft Holsters is an excellent choice, offering premium leather holsters tailored for a custom fit, ensuring comfort, retention, and quick draw—all at a reasonable price. Known for craftsmanship and attention to detail, Craft Holsters provides high-quality options for users who prioritize both durability and functionality in a holster for Smith and Wesson 686.
One of the top picks is the Smith and Wesson 686 Cross Draw Holster. This cross-draw holster allows for a smooth, quick draw from a comfortable position, ideal for those who prefer carrying their 686 in an accessible yet discreet manner. Made from premium leather, it contours to your body over time, providing excellent retention and comfort throughout the day
.Another great option is the Smith and Wesson 686 Leather Chest Holster, perfect for outdoor enthusiasts who need a holster that allows for freedom of movement. Designed to carry across the chest, it offers superb retention and stability, making it ideal for hiking or camping. Crafted from premium leather, it provides a comfortable and secure fit for quick access to your revolver in outdoor settings.
Craft Holsters combines quality materials, functional design, and reasonable prices, making them a trusted source for the best Smith and Wesson 686 holsters.
Conclusion - Should I buy Smith and Wesson 686 despite its problems?
Despite a few common issues—such as cylinder binding, ejector rod loosening, and a heavy trigger pull—the Smith and Wesson 686 remains a dependable .357 Magnum revolver for those who value power and precision. Each of these problems has practical solutions, and with the guidance provided in this article, you now know how to address these issues effectively. Choosing the right Smith and Wesson 686 holster is just as crucial, ensuring comfort, retention, and quick access, all essential for an optimal carry experience.
The Smith & Wesson 686 is an excellent choice for experienced shooters who need a reliable revolver for home defense or outdoor use, where durability and stopping power matter most. However, it may not be ideal for beginners or those seeking a lightweight, high-capacity option for daily concealed carry. With the right setup and a quality holster, the Smith and Wesson 686 can serve as a trustworthy and powerful addition to your firearm collection.
