WIN 5,000 ROUNDS OF 9mm AMMO! - More Info

Craft Holsters - Blog - Investing in Firearms: Best Guns to Collect

Investing in Firearms: Best Guns to Collect

Check out our holster bestsellers - Shop Now Check out our holster bestsellers - Shop Now
Investing in firearms Investing in firearms Investing in firearms

Table of Contents

 

U.S. collector’s guide to investing in firearms, identifying collectible guns, and checking antique gun values. 

Firearms have been used for generations as valuable collectibles as well as defensive and recreational tools. While most modern models depreciate like cars, some antique firearms and proven classics have shown steady appreciation—making them desirable long‑term assets for gun collecting in the United States.

This article explains the models and characteristics that, from both collector and investor perspectives, can make a gun genuinely interesting. It also covers accessories—especially holsters—that can add value. Over time, there has been consistent respect for vintage military‑issued leather holsters, custom‑made pieces, and original pairings with firearms. Below, we outline the best guns to collect, how to evaluate pricing, and how holsters can become investments, too (always follow applicable federal and state laws; this guide is informational, not legal advice).

 

Appreciaton Rates by Firearm Category

Diagram 1: Firearm Categories and Value Trends, Source: Rock Island Auction Company, Morphy Auctions, Blue Book of Gun Values (2003–2023 market trends).

 

Factors That Affect Value  

 

Not every firearm becomes a high‑end collectible. Many elements—historical significance, rarity, condition & originality, cultural impact, and brand reputation—shape whether a gun will hold or gain value.

Guns with rare origins, unique backstories, or restricted production runs are frequently valued higher by collectors. The secret to determining which firearms will become long-term investments and which will remain essentially useful tools is to comprehend these aspects. 

 

Factor Example Firearm Typical Auction Range*
Cultural Impact Desert Eagle (Hollywood fame) $1,500 – $3,500
Historical Significance WWII M1 Garand Rifle $2,000 – $5,000
Brand Reputation Colt 1911 Classic $2,500 – $7,000
Condition & Originality Unfired S&W Model 29 $3,000 – $6,000
Rarity & Production Colt Python (low production) $4,000 – $10,000+

 

Tab 1: How Collectors Decide Value — Factors, Examples & Prices  *Ranges are illustrative and depend on provenance, variant, and market conditions 

 

  • Historical Significance – Guns linked to pivotal owners, battles, or units have timeless appeal.
  • Rarity & Production Numbers – Discontinued, low‑volume, or unique variants often appreciated.
  • Condition & Originality – Matching serials, factory parts, and original finish strongly influence antique gun values.
  • Cultural Impact – Models immortalized in film, TV, literature, or law‑enforcement history see elevated demand.
  • Brand Reputation – Names like Colt, Smith & Wesson, and Winchester command premium interest among collectible guns.

 

How Collectors Decide Value

Infographic 1: U.S. Collector Gun Price Ranges, Data from Blue Book of Gun Values and major U.S. auction house, Note: Price ranges are illustrative. Actual values depend on provenance, condition, originality. 

 

Cultural Impact - Desert Eagle 

Desert Eagle .50 Action Express

 

The Desert Eagle, which was first launched in the 1980s, is one of the most well-known pistols in the world due to its widespread use in popular culture rather than military use. Its large frame and unique appearance made it an obvious choice for filmmakers, especially since it was chambered in heavy calibers like.44 Magnum and.50 AE.

It has been included in innumerable films, such as Austin Powers, RoboCop, Snatch, The Last Action Hero, Demolition Man, and The Matrix. Additionally, the pistol is a common feature in video games like Far Cry, Max Payne, Counter-Strike, and Call of Duty. Early production and special-finish Desert Eagles are highly sought after by collectors and frequently cost between $1,500 and $3,500 at auction, despite not being rare or historically significant. This makes it a perfect illustration of how a firearm's status in the collector market may be raised purely by cultural influence.

 

Historical significance - M1 Garand (rifle) 

M1 Garand rifle

 

The M1 Garand is an excellent illustration of a handgun that combines heritage with high investment potential. The chart mentioned earlier clearly demonstrates the element of historical relevance, as a rifle associated with significant global events continues to attract collectors. Its original parts and confirmed WWII service have caused its auction prices to gradually increase into the $2,000–$5,000 range.

During World War II and the Korean War, American forces' standard-issue service rifle was the M1 Garand, officially known as the U.S. Rifle, Caliber.30, M1. It gained a legendary reputation for dependability and firepower after General George S. Patton described it as "the greatest battle implement ever devised." Examples from the WWII era that have the right paperwork or genuine parts are in great demand today, and their prices at auction are continuously rising. In addition to its military importance, the M1 Garand is prized by collectors as a key piece of American gun history.

 

Condition & Originality - The Unfired S&W Model 29 

Smith and Wesson .44 Magnum 29

 

The Smith & Wesson Model 29, chambered in .44 Magnum, became an icon after Clint Eastwood’s Dirty Harry films of the 1970s. While standard examples remain collectible, unfired, original-condition Model 29s are especially prized because they represent the rarest state of preservation.

Firing a revolver, even a single round, leaves microscopic wear on the cylinder and barrel, immediately reducing it from “mint” to merely “excellent” condition — a distinction that can mean thousands of dollars at auction. Collectors pay a premium for revolvers with untouched bores, factory finish, and original packaging, with prices often ranging from $3,000 to $6,000 depending on configuration. This model demonstrates how condition and originality can dramatically elevate a firearm’s investment value, even for guns that were mass-produced.

For S&W Model 29 owners, our leather and optic-ready holsters offer superior comfort - see the selection here.

 

Brand reputation - Colt 1911 Classic 

Colt M1911A1 gun

 

John Browning's design, which was formally accepted by the US Army in 1911 as the Model 1911, is the source of the Colt 1911 Classic. Built on a short-recoil, semi-automatic system and chambered in.45 ACP, it established a new standard for stopping power and reliability.

Through World Wars I, II, Korea, and Vietnam, it served as America's standard-issue sidearm and came to represent military reliability. The 1911 became not just a sidearm but also a cultural and historical icon as a result of its long service history, which reinforced Colt's reputation.

Early serial numbers and commemorative versions may sell for $2,500 to $7,000 or more at auction, while even Colts with regular production have a high market value. The Colt 1911 is the ideal example of how military heritage, established design, and brand reputation come together to provide lasting collector value.

 

Rarity and Production Numbers - The Colt Python 

Colt Python

 

The Colt Python is the ideal illustration of how production volume and rarity contribute to long-term value. It was Colt's flagship revolver when it was first introduced in 1955. It had exceptional hand-fitting and finish and was made in small quantities. Due to the supply being permanently capped when Colt withdrew the line in 2005, collectors hurried to fill the void.

As a result, original-production Pythons are now much more valuable, and their auction prices can range from $4,000 to over $10,000, depending on their condition and variant. This makes the Python an excellent illustration of how discontinued, low-volume weapons may become highly sought-after investment products.

If you’re a proud owner of the Colt Python, don’t miss our full range of suitable Colt Python holsters here. 

 

Top Guns That Gained Value in the Last 20 Years 

 

In the last twenty years, a number of firearms have become especially valuable investments in the U.S. collector market. With rare examples reaching $10,000, the Colt Python revolver has experienced rapid development, going from under $500 to well over $4,000 in flawless condition. Particularly when linked to military service, the cost of WWII-era M1 Garand rifles has almost doubled.

The once-overlooked first-generation Glock 17 has unexpectedly gained more than 200% in value and is now a sought-after item. In the meantime, limited-edition and customized 1911s from manufacturers such as Ed Brown and Wilson Combat maintain their worth and increase. Collectively, these examples demonstrate how cultural influence, rarity, and historical relevance influence antique gun values and modern collectibility.

In both private and auction markets, certain types of firearms have continuously performed better than others:

  • Colt Python Revolvers –  Once selling for less than $500, flawless Pythons are now valued between $4,000 and $6,000, with rarer models reaching $10,000.
  • WWII-Era M1 Garand Rifles – Since the early 2000s, prices have almost risen, particularly for documented wartime era models.
  • First-Generation Glock 17 – In under twenty years, Gen 1 models of early polymer pistols have increased in value by 200–300%, making them collectible.
  • Custom & Limited-Edition 1911s – Colt Anniversary, Ed Brown, and Wilson Combat models all have high resale value.

 

Firearms that Skyrocketed in Value

Diagram 2: Ranking firearms by % increase in auction sales, Source: Rock Island Auction Company, Morphy Auctions, and collector price guides (2003–2023) 

 

This infographic shows how the value of various firearms has increased over the past 20 years, with the Colt Python seeing the most increase at over 400%. While bespoke 1911s continue to keep stable in value, early-production polymer handguns like the Glock Gen1 and classic military weapons like the M1 Garand also show significant rises. Collectively, these examples show how long-term investment potential in firearms is influenced by elements like rarity, history, and cultural effect.

These prices show how provenance and historical relevance may elevate weapons to the status of valuable collectibles. These items tell stories connected to historical personalities and events, unlike contemporary firearms that usually lose value over time. They demonstrate to collectors that a firearm can serve as both a weapon and a valuable artifact under proper conditions.

 

Top 5 Most Expensive Guns Ever Sold at Auction

 

Some firearms transcend utility to become national‑heritage artifacts. George Washington's pair of saddle pistols, which sold at Christie's in 2002 for about $1.986 million, making them the most expensive firearms ever auctioned, was one of the most well-known sales.

Other significant examples are Admiral Nelson's Flintlock Pistols, which sold for $721,000, and Sam Houston's Colt Walker, which brought in $920,000. At Rock Island Auction, the renowned Winchester "One of One Thousand" sold for nearly $500,000, while the Colt.45 that killed Jesse James brought in $350,000.

 

Top 5 expensive guns

Infographic 2: Most Valuable Firearms Ever Sold, Data based on reported auction results (Christie’s, Heritage, Bonhams, Rock Island, 2002–2018) 

 

Where to Buy: Auctions vs. Private Sales 

 

Collectors can purchase valuable firearms through a variety of channels, including elite auctions, private sales, and exciting gun exhibitions. Every choice has its own benefits, dangers, and chances for locating parts that are worth investing in. 

 

Buying Method Pros Cons
Auctions ✅ High-end pieces, authentication, global visibility ❌ Prices may soar, buyer’s premiums
Private Sales ✅ Discreet, room for negotiation ❌ Risk of replicas, less transparency
Gun Shows & Specialty Dealers ✅ Networking, learning, undervalued finds ❌ Quality varies, fewer guarantees

Tab 2. – Firearm Marketplaces Comparison 

 

Auctions

 

High-end collectors from all over the world are drawn to major houses like Heritage, Bonhams, and Rock Island Auction Company. They are a reliable source for valuable and uncommon firearms since these events offer global visibility and authenticity. However, bidding wars can cause prices to rise much over normal market ranges, and purchasers also have to factor in premiums and fees. 

 

Private Sales 

 

More discretion is available in private transactions, and purchasers may be able to strike advantageous terms. They may be a great opportunity to acquire one-of-a-kind items away from the spotlight of an auction. But authenticity is a risk; without the necessary knowledge, collectors could come across fakes, modified firearms, or weapons with the wrong history. 

 

Gun Shows & Specialty Dealers* 

 

Networking with other collectors is possible at gun shows and specialist dealers for a more intimate and community-focused experience. These places are great for learning firsthand from seasoned collectors and for finding undervalued jewels before they make it to auction houses. Shows and specialist dealers are great for novice collectors looking for chances and knowledge, even though high-value items could be less common. 

* Compliance note (U.S.): Laws vary by state. Always follow federal and state regulations, including background checks and required FFL transfers for non‑antique firearms. Store and insure valuables appropriately. 

 

Holsters That Collectors Want 

 

Despite their simplicity, holsters can be valuable and exciting collectibles. Rare pieces from renowned makers, custom Western rigs, and WWII‑era military‑issued leather holsters are sought after—especially when paired with the original firearm.

  • Military-Issued Leather Holsters: The U.S. M1916 holster (for the Colt M1911) is a classic example. Prices for genuine, marked specimens have climbed in the last decade, often $75–$200+ depending on markings and condition.
  • Custom Maker Holsters: Heiser, Bucheimer, and S.D. Myers pieces blend craftsmanship and utility. Vintage examples now range from a few hundred to several thousand dollars, driven by maker reputation and originality.
  • Paired Provenance: A factory‑stamped leather rig paired with its original handgun frequently increases overall sale price. Collectors value historically complete sets.

 

Risks and Red Flags in Firearm Collecting 

 

Scammers and dishonest tactics have also been drawn to the growing market for collectible firearms. There are several ways to trick unwary shoppers, ranging from spoof retailer websites to phony auction listings and fake bidding. There are hazards at every stage of the industry, as evidenced by data breaches and fraud that have occurred on even the biggest online platforms. Collectors who wish to safeguard their money and personal safety must be aware of these dangers. 

 

Firearm collecting advice ladder

1. Online Auction Scams and Fake Listings 

  • Some scammers produce convincing but fake auction advertising by reusing photos from legitimate auctions, occasionally even screenshots from video reviews. These fake listings are frequently easily discovered through Google reverse image searches.   
  • Red flags on sites like GunBroker include ads with duplicate photos from other sources, missing seller feedback, and unusually cheap prices. These frequently imply frauds. 

2. Fraudulent Auction Practices 

  • The problem of auction fraud is still more widespread in online markets. Bid shielding, phony listings, non-delivery after sale, and shill bidding—fake bids to raise prices—are common examples.   
  • Even though upscale gun auction shops typically have rigorous authenticity checks, errors and disputes can still happen, which emphasizes the value of being cautious. 

3. Spoofed Retailers and Shooter Pay-Days 

  • Scam websites impersonating trustworthy gun dealers are becoming a bigger menace, according to The American Rifleman. These frequently deceive customers by using bad site design or mistakes in URLs (such as "Ruger-usa.biz" instead of "ruger-usa.com").
  • Millions of dollars have been lost by consumers as a result of gun-related frauds, and the FBI and FTC have warned that purchasers are being tricked by offers on fraudulent websites. 

4. Data Breaches from Auction Platforms 

  • Beyond frauds, there is an increasing risk to privacy: in 2023, hackers gained access to the identities of more than 550,000 people by hacking GunAuction.com, a website that sells firearms. 

 

FAQ

They can be—especially collectible guns with documented originality, strong demand, and verifiable provenance. Treat firearms like any collectible: research comps, inspect condition, and factor fees and storage. 

U.S. favorites include select revolvers (e.g., early Colt Python), classic service rifles (e.g., WWII M1 Garand), and genuinely scarce antique firearms and limited‑run 1911s. 

Identify the exact model/variant, verify matching serials and factory finish, review documentation, then triangulate price using recent U.S. auction results, dealer listings, and recognized guides. 

No. Focus on low‑production, high‑quality runs with documented origin. Many commemoratives underperform compared to truly scarce variants.

Authentic provenance usually comes with supporting documentation, such as military records, factory letters, or auction certificates. Always cross-check claims with independent sources like collector associations or manufacturer archives. Be cautious of vague stories or sellers unwilling to provide verifiable paperwork. 

Stick to established platforms like Rock Island Auction, Morphy, or GunBroker sellers with strong reputations and reviews. Always verify photos and descriptions, and avoid listings that seem suspiciously cheap. When in doubt, ask for additional images, documentation, or use an escrow service for high-value deals. 

 

Conclusion 

 

A clear divide has emerged: historically important antique guns and low‑production classics often appreciate, while mass‑produced modern pistols typically depreciate. By focusing on provenance, rarity, originality, and brand reputation—and by validating antique gun values with multiple U.S. comps—enthusiasts can build collections that endure both culturally and financially. For many readers, this is the practical core of investing in firearms and choosing the best guns to collect. 

 

References 

 

Tags: Gun Talk

SHOP WITH CONFIDENCE